Note: The authoritative copy of this page is now found on GitHub:Gist.
Fanfiction readers and reviewers
A micro-review of a work of fanfiction intended to aid potential readers in finding new entertainment.
#fic_rating <rating> [details] <url>
A value from 1.0 through 5.0 in steps of 0.5
- 4 of 5
A sentence or two satisfying as many of the following criteria as possible:
- Tells the reader which series is/are being used as a base. (eg. Mention a distinctive character/place name, job title, etc.)
- Conveys why a reader would want to read this particular story. (Ideally, the core plot concept... but if that's common, the plot element you enjoyed most is a good candidate)
- In the case of a poor rating, quickly details what's wrong with the story.
Voluntary standardization of ratings also benefits readers. In my experience, the following interpretations of ratings tend to hold true:
- 1.0: Literally unreadable
- 2.0: So out-of-character it's painful.
- 3.0: Ho-hum. Nothing bad, but nothing good either. (Boring)
- 4.0: Good.
- 5.0: Excellent.
I advise reserving half ratings for stories firmly on the borderline between two integer ratings or where one aspect deserves a high rating but another deserves a low one. (eg. A great story horribly in need of proofreading or a story that started out excellent and then got stale.)
Use of detail levels beyond half-ratings is advised against as it generally becomes difficult for the reviewer to accurately determine what rating a story deserves. (You'll end up either having inaccurate ratings or having to go back and re-tweet old ratings to correct the decimal portion to a more appropriate value relative to a new story you've found)
At the top end (5.0), ratings can be a little vague ("Excellent" vs. "Award-winning") but, after a lot of thought, the best solution I've come up with is simply to use awards or a shortlist to denote the handful of stories that are beyond excellent. To do otherwise tends to run into problems with how people interpret ratings.
Finally, if you have an account on a StatusNet-based service like Identi.ca on which you post notices using #fic_rating on a reasonably regular basis, you are invited to add "ficratings" (plural, no underscore) to the "Tags for yourself" field in your profile.